top of page
_edited.png
Search

Social Media Investigations in Personal Injury Cases: What Posts Can (and Can't) Prove

Brendon Carl
Nov 5
5 min read

A social media investigation can be the difference between a fair settlement and a blown-up claim. In a St. Louis bicyclist injury case this year, a plaintiff asked a jury for $910,000 in pain and suffering. The defense showed the jury about ten of his Instagram photos — him biking, hiking, jet skiing, and kayaking after the crash, despite testifying he had stopped riding and had trouble walking long distances. The jury came back with a full defense verdict: 100% fault to the plaintiff, $0 in damages. The case was Bouasba v. St. Louis County Cab Company (St. Louis County Circuit Court, Case No. 22SL-CC02586, verdict April 29, 2026), and it is the clearest recent reminder of something every injury attorney already suspects: the claimant's own phone is often the best witness in the room.


Here's what a social media investigation actually is, what it can and can't prove, and how it fits with the rest of the work an investigator does on an injury case.

What a Social Media Investigation Actually Is

A social media investigation is a systematic review of what a person has posted — and

what's been posted about them — across public platforms: Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, X, YouTube, LinkedIn, and anywhere else their life shows up online. It's not scrolling through someone's feed for ten minutes. A real investigation captures the posts with dates, timestamps, and context, preserves them in a way that holds up in court, and ties each item back to a specific claim the person made: "I can't walk," "I can't work," "I can't lift anything."


The point isn't to find one embarrassing photo. It's to build a timeline. A single picture of a claimant at a barbecue proves nothing on its own. A pattern — hiking in March, a 5K in April, a kayaking trip in May, all while the medical records say the person can barely get out of a chair — that's a different story, and it's the kind of story that changes settlement numbers.

What a Claimant's Posts Can Prove

Inconsistency with claimed limitations. This is the big one, and it's what won the St. Louis case. When someone testifies they can't ride a bike and their Instagram shows them riding a bike, credibility takes the hit, not just that one claim. Juries notice, and so do adjusters.

Activity levels and timelines. Posts are time-stamped. That matters when a claimant says the injury kept them home for six months but their own feed shows a vacation two months after the accident. The dates do the arguing.

Who they spend time with, and where. Check-ins and tags from friends can place a person somewhere they said they weren't — or confirm they were exactly where they said they were. Either way, it answers a question.

What a Claimant's Posts Can't Prove

A photo doesn't prove a person is pain-free. A smiling photo at a family gathering doesn't mean the person wasn't hurting an hour later. One good afternoon doesn't undo a documented injury, and a jury can smell it when the defense overreaches. The St. Louis verdict worked because the photos showed a sustained pattern of the exact activities the plaintiff said he couldn't do — not because he smiled in one picture.

Private posts aren't automatically fair game. Public posts carry no reasonable expectation of privacy — anyone can look at them. Private content is different: in Texas and most states, it can be obtained through discovery when it's relevant to the claims, but an investigator can't hack an account, friend someone under false pretenses, or trick their way in. The New York Court of Appeals said it plainly in Forman v. Henkin (2018): private social media material is discoverable when relevant, but it goes through the court, not through a back door.

A post can't prove what happened at the scene. Social media tells you about the claimant's life after the accident. It says nothing about who ran the red light. Don't let a good social media file distract from the scene documentation, witness statements, and medical records that actually prove liability.

How Attorneys Should Use a Social Media Investigation

Start early, before anything gets deleted. The first thing an investigator does is preserve what's public right now, because posts disappear. Once a claim or lawsuit is underway, deleting posts can be spoliation — and courts can hit a plaintiff with an adverse-inference instruction for it. But a post that's already gone is gone, and no investigator can bring it back. Get the preservation done at intake, not at mediation.

Pair it with surveillance, don't substitute it. A social media file tells you where to look and when. Field surveillance tells you whether the picture matches real life. We wrote about that pairing in our post on surveillance in injury cases — the two tools do different jobs, and a case is strongest when they agree. Posts point the surveillance in the right direction; surveillance confirms what the posts suggest.

Use it to test your own client's story, too. The best time to find out your client has a public Instagram full of CrossFit videos is before the deposition, not during it. A good investigator reports what they find either way, and a good attorney would rather hear the bad news early.

Keep the chain of custody clean. Screenshots with no metadata, no date, and no source are weak evidence. A professional investigation preserves posts with timestamps, URLs, and capture methods documented, so the other side can't argue the evidence was cherry-picked or altered.

What Texas Attorneys Need to Know

In Texas, private investigation work — including

social media investigations and surveillance — has to be done by a licensed investigator under the Texas Occupations Code, Chapter 1702, regulated by the Department of Public Safety. That's not a technicality. Unlicensed investigation can get evidence excluded and create problems for the attorney who used it.

WinWin Investigations handles social media investigations, surveillance, witness locates, and scene documentation for personal injury attorneys — Texas only. Our investigators are licensed, and the work is documented the way a court expects to see it. If you need a witness found, read our post on witness locates for how that side of the work runs.

One more thing worth saying plainly: we investigate claims, not people. The job is to find out what's true, whether it helps your case or not. An investigator who only brings back good news isn't doing the job — and an attorney who only wants good news is setting themselves up for a bad surprise at trial.

If you're a Texas personal injury attorney and you want a social media investigation done right — or surveillance, a witness locate, or scene documentation — that's what we do.

Ready to Get Started?

Process serving, nationwide: https://www.winwinps.org/place-order

Local Travis/Williamson County process serving: https://www.winwinps.org/place-an-order-l


We serve papers nationwide — Routine $125 / Rush $195 / Same Day $299 — and local Williamson and Travis County service at Routine $95 / Rush $155 / Same Day $250. We've spent twelve years in process serving across Texas and California, and our investigation work is Texas-only, licensed, and documented to hold up in court.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


WinWin Logo

Mission statement:

​

"To provide superior process serving solutions through superior work ethic, exceptional reliability, and dedicated professionalism, creating winning outcomes for every client we serve."

Resources:

NAPPS Logo
TPSA Member
ServeNow Affiliate
bottom of page